← StudyX Devlog

Ten Habit Tips for Studying: Research on Building Habits for Students Who Struggle to Keep Going

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperBrain MondoBrainDojo

Brain Mondo · 23 of 23

Ten Habit Tips for Studying: Research on Building Habits for Students Who Struggle to Keep Going

A large American company sent its employees a mailing about free flu shots. Among employees who got only the mailing, 33.1% were vaccinated. When the mailing also had a space to write down the date they planned to go, the rate was 1.5 points higher, a difference that was not statistically significant. When it had a space for both a date and a time, the rate was 4.2 points higher. That is from an experiment by Milkman and colleagues, published in PNAS in 2011.

Brain Mondo has published a video that picks ten studies like this one on building habits and puts them in order: the day you start, goals and plans, cues, and ways to keep going. Each point has one paper as its source. Most of the studies tested behaviors such as exercise and shopping, not studying itself. In this post I go through the ten papers from the video, together with the conditions of each study and some cautions for reading them.

Video: Habit tips for people who can’t keep up their exam study: ten picks (Japanese)

The video is in Japanese.

The day you start

1. Start on a dividing line in time

One study looked at three sets of real-world records (Dai and colleagues, 2014, Management Science): Google searches for “diet”, gym visits, and sign-ups on a site where people commit to goals. All three went up after temporal landmarks such as the start of a new week, month, year or semester, a birthday, or a holiday. The authors call this the “fresh start effect.”

In their view, these landmarks create many new periods within a year. Past failures get assigned to the previous period, people take a big-picture view of their lives, and that motivates them to work toward goals. This is an analysis of records, though, and the video notes that it cannot show a cause.

Goals and plans

2. Set a somewhat difficult goal, in front of others

A meta-analysis gathered randomized controlled trials that measured the effect of goal setting on its own (Epton and colleagues, 2017, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology). It drew 384 effect sizes from 141 papers, 16,523 people in total. Setting goals had a small positive effect across a range of behaviors.

The effect was especially large when the goal was difficult, set publicly, or a group goal. There was also a result that goal setting worked better when others monitored the behavior or outcome and when it was delivered face to face, but the evidence for that was weaker.

3. Decide on the obstacles, and what you will do about them

First you picture the goal achieved, then the obstacle that stands in its way. Then you decide what you will do when that obstacle comes, in the form “if this happens, I will do that.” A meta-analysis combined 21 studies of this method, with 24 effect sizes and 15,907 participants (Wang and colleagues, 2021, Frontiers in Psychology). It had a small to medium effect on reaching goals.

Studies where participants worked with an experimenter had larger effects than studies that used only written materials. The authors also write that because of publication bias, the actual effect may be somewhat smaller. I wrote more about the “if this, then that” method itself in the post on implementation intentions.

4. Decide on a time, not just a date

This is the Milkman experiment from the opening. Every employee received a mailing with the times and places of the free on-site clinics. For employees chosen at random, the mailing also had a space to write the date they planned to get the shot, or the date and the time.

The space for a date alone made no clear difference compared with the mailing only. The difference came with the space for a date and a time. Both groups were asked to write a plan, and the result split on how specific the plan was.

Cues

5. Repeat in the same setting

One study followed the exercise, newspaper reading and TV watching habits of students transferring to a new university (Wood and colleagues, 2005, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology). The habits survived the move only when some part of the setting stayed the same. One example is a student who kept reading the newspaper with other people, as before.

In other words, the usual setting acts as the cue for a habit. When the setting changed and the habit broke, people sometimes started acting on the intentions they held at the time. The video notes that this is an observational study, so it cannot show a cause. This study also appears in the post on stale popcorn at the movies.

Ways to keep going

6. Pair it with something you enjoy

In one experiment, page-turner audiobooks could be heard only at the gym (Milkman and colleagues, 2014, Management Science). Participants were randomly assigned to a group with gym-only access to the audiobooks, a group encouraged to listen only at the gym, or a control group.

At first, compared with the control group, gym visits were 51% higher in the gym-only group and 29% higher in the encouraged group. The effect faded over time, though, dropping especially after Thanksgiving. After the study, 61% of participants chose to pay for gym-only access to the audiobooks.

7. Keep a record of your progress

A meta-analysis combined 138 studies, 19,951 people in total, that randomly assigned participants to an intervention prompting them to monitor their progress toward a goal (Harkin and colleagues, 2016, Psychological Bulletin). People who were prompted checked their progress much more often, and they also made more progress toward their goals. The increase in checking was what carried the effect on reaching the goal.

The effect was especially large when results were reported to others or made public, and when the information was physically recorded, on paper for example.

8. Make a promise in advance about what happens if you fall short

In one experiment, households in a program that gave 25% off healthy groceries were offered a deal (Schwartz and colleagues, 2014, Psychological Science). For each of 6 months, they would raise their purchases of healthy food by 5 percentage points above their usual level. If they reached that goal, they got the discount as usual. If not, they lost the discount for that month.

Of the households offered the deal, 36% accepted. Those households raised healthy food purchases by an average of 3.5 points in every one of the 6 months. Households that declined, and a control group that was only given a hypothetical option to commit, showed no such increase. The authors write that self-aware consumers will take chances to limit their own choices, even at some risk of losing money.

9. Watch out for bad habits to stop them

This study combines two diary studies, in which people recorded their daily behavior, and one experiment (Quinn and colleagues, 2010, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin). What worked best to stop bad habits was vigilant monitoring: thinking “don’t do it” and watching carefully for slipups.

Staying away from the cue helped with resisting temptations. For strong habits, though, monitoring was the only strategy that helped. The follow-up experiment showed that monitoring does not weaken the memory of the habit itself, but strengthens the processes that hold back a response. Like the fifth study, this one also appears in the post on stale popcorn at the movies.

10. Miss a day, then keep going

In one study, 96 volunteers each chose an eating, drinking or activity behavior and did it every day for 12 weeks in the same setting, such as “after breakfast” (Lally and colleagues, published online in 2009, European Journal of Social Psychology). Every day they recorded whether they had done it and answered a questionnaire on how automatic it felt.

For the 82 people whose data could be analyzed, it took from 18 to 254 days for automaticity to get close to its ceiling. It varied widely from person to person and could take a very long time. And missing one chance to do the behavior had almost no effect on how the habit formed. I wrote more about this study in the post on how long it takes to form a habit.

Cautions for reading

None of the ten studies looked at studying itself. They tested other behaviors, such as flu shots, exercise, grocery shopping, and reading the newspaper or watching TV.

The studies are not equally strong. The first is an analysis of records and the fifth is observational, so neither can show a cause. The second, third and seventh are meta-analyses, and the third has a note about publication bias. In the sixth, the effect faded over time. In the eighth, the households that committed were the 36% who chose to accept. The tenth had 82 people, and the number of days varied widely between them.

All of them are results under the conditions of each study.

Using it in daily life

The video suggests trying just one of them first. Following the conditions the studies tested, it looks like this.

  • Write your plan with a date and a time. In the fourth study, the difference came from the space for a date and a time, not the space for a date alone.
  • Make your goal somewhat difficult, and tell people about it. In the second study, the effect was larger for difficult goals and goals set in public.
  • Write your progress down, on paper for example. In the seventh study, the effect was larger when progress was recorded, and when it was reported to others or made public.
  • Repeat in the same setting, and after missing a day, go back to the same setting. This follows the fifth and tenth studies.

Brain Mondo introduces research-based stories about the brain, in top-ten videos and short videos. BrainDojo is an app for training calculation, memory, attention and more in a few minutes a day.

References

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habits