← StudyX Devlog

Playing Piano Hands Together: Melody, Accompaniment, Then Both Hands

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperKinder PianoHow-To
Playing Piano Hands Together: Melody, Accompaniment, Then Both Hands

When you play with both hands, the right hand and the left hand usually press different keys at different times. The right hand may play C, D, E, F, G while the left hand holds a single C. A child can play the right hand alone and the left hand alone, and still stop the moment the two go together. Playing each hand and playing both at once are not the same skill.

This post is about that step from one hand to two: an order to work in, and ways to practice the join.

One hand, then two

An opinion article by Pang and colleagues, published in Frontiers in Psychology in 2023, describes the common approach in piano practice as part-whole: practice each hand alone first, then put both together. The authors then point out that practice with one hand may not fully carry over to playing with two.

The same article suggests that right-handed learners give the left hand particular attention. This is a proposal, not a tested result, and the authors write that its effect still needs to be shown in future research.

One way to see it, then, is that being able to play each hand does not finish the preparation. Putting the hands together is a practice task of its own.

Melody, accompaniment, both hands

Here is one order to work in.

First, the melody. In most children’s pieces this is the right hand, the part you can sing. The melody-only stage is also covered in Practical Tips for Using Kinder Piano Every Day.

Second, the accompaniment alone. The child plays the left-hand part with the left hand, all the way through. Even when it has fewer notes than the melody, playing it through means that when the hands meet, both parts are already familiar. For a right-handed child, another approach, in line with the article above, is to give the left hand a little more time.

Third, both hands.

How long to stay with one hand is a matter of approach. Some wait until each hand is secure. Others start putting the hands together, very slowly, as soon as each hand roughly works. The article’s point that one-hand practice may not fully carry over sits closer to the second approach.

Practicing the join in small pieces

Rather than starting from the top of the piece, one method is to take a short section, one or two bars.

Within that section, you can pull out the notes the two hands play at the same moment. In the bar from the start of this post, where the right hand plays C, D, E, F, G over a held C in the left hand, the hands press together only once, on the first C. Get that one moment together first, then add D, E, F and G in the right hand while the left hand keeps holding.

On speed, there is a study worth knowing. In a 2009 study by Duke, Simmons and Cash in the Journal of Research in Music Education, 17 advanced piano students practiced a difficult three-bar passage from a Shostakovich concerto and played it again the next day. How well they played the next day was not significantly related to how long they practiced or how many times they played it. What did relate was the share of practice trials they played correctly: the higher that share, the better the next-day performance.

The participants were university piano majors, not children, and there were only 17 of them. Still, one way to apply it is to slow down to a speed where the passage comes out right, and repeat it there, instead of running through it with mistakes.

If the hands come apart at the same spot every time, another method is to go back to one hand for that spot only. There is more on stepping back in When Your Child Refuses to Practice Piano. A parent can also play the left hand while the child plays the right-hand melody, so the two of you make the two-hand sound together; that split is described in Piano Duets: How a Parent and Child Can Split the Parts. Finger numbers are in Piano Finger Numbers, and hand shape is in Piano Hand Position and Posture.

Moving to both hands in Kinder Piano

In Kinder Piano, when a song has an accompaniment, the app asks “What will you play?” and offers Melody, Accompaniment and Both hands. Accompaniment is the left-hand part. Both hands shows the treble and bass staves together and has the child play with both hands. The order in this post means working down that list one at a time.

In Rhythm mode, if you choose Melody or Accompaniment, the app plays the other part. The child plays one hand and hears the other hand’s notes at the same time. In Slow mode with Both hands, wherever notes in the two hands fall together, the app waits until both keys are pressed. Either hand can go first.

Kinder Piano is a piano app for iPhone and iPad for children from about age 3 to the early years of elementary school. I made it for my four-year-old daughter. All 21 nursery songs are free, as are the first classical piece and the first ear training level, free play and MIDI connection. A single one-time purchase opens the rest of the classical pieces and every ear training level. There are no ads and no subscription.

The path to the first song is in Getting Started with Kinder Piano.

Download on the App Store

Kinder PianoA first piano for little hands