← StudyX Devlog

Piano Posture for Children: Bench Height and Hand Shape

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara ¡ DeveloperKinder PianoHow-To
Piano Posture for Children: Bench Height and Hand Shape

Yamaha’s Musical Instrument Guide gives bench height in one sentence: “Adjust the height of the piano bench so that your elbows are almost level with the keyboard.”

This article collects what a few sources say about bench height, sitting, feet and hand shape at the piano: that Yamaha page, and pages on the site of PTNA, the Piano Teachers’ National Association of Japan, where piano teachers answer questions from other teachers. The PTNA pages are in Japanese. Wrists and playing on a screen keyboard are covered in Piano Hand Position and Posture: What to Tell Young Children.

Where the bench goes and how to sit

The Yamaha page says to center the bench to the width of the keyboard, facing the piano squarely, and to sit toward the front half of the bench. Your weight is centered on your buttocks, and your feet are flat on the ground from heel to toe. Shoulders and arms are relaxed and the back is straight, so that everything up to the fingertips can move smoothly.

In PTNA’s teachers’ Q&A series, number 25 (2019), a teacher asked what to do about a student whose fingertips are weak and floppy. The answer, from Yukiko Watanabe, starts not with the fingertips but with a posture that lets the student put body weight into them. She lists four points:

  1. A footrest that fits the child’s body. A thick book such as a dictionary can be used to adjust the height.
  2. Bench height: the arm just slightly off level, in a gentle へ shape (a Japanese character that rises and then falls).
  3. Distance from the piano: the elbows between the piano and the body, with one fist’s width between the arm and the side.
  4. Sitting: sit slightly forward with the knees a little apart. The upper body is vertical and the shoulders are relaxed.

Bench height

According to Yamaha, it is difficult to play with your wrists and elbows much lower than the keyboard. The guide is the one at the top: elbows almost level with the keys.

A 2013 research report on PTNA’s site, “A comparison of teaching methods for basic piano technique”, compares what several piano method books say. Its conclusion is that a line from the forearm to the back of the hand that is almost level is the standard, with some freedom for the player’s preference and the character of the piece. A bench far too high or far too low, the report says, either puts extra strain on the arms and hands or makes the sound weak, as if only brushing the surface of the keys.

When the feet don’t reach the floor

At that height, a child’s feet often don’t reach the floor. The same report says so directly: a child’s body is too small for the piano, so keeping the hands and fingers in position means the heels can’t touch the floor, and a footrest should be used at a height where the legs can come straight down.

The footrest is also the first of Watanabe’s four points.

Hand shape

Yamaha’s guide describes the hand on the keys this way: “Imagine holding an egg in the palm of your hand.” It says this relaxes the hands and lets you play smoothly.

Watanabe describes the finger shape that makes a good sound as one where every joint of the finger stands out and the fingertip meets the key at an angle of 45 degrees. To find the shape, she suggests lightly making a fist and then gently spreading the fingertips, holding a ball a little bigger than your hand, or bringing the fingertips together as if scooping water to drink and then turning the hand over.

She also gives an order. First make the shape on a table, then on the closed lid over the keys, then rest the hand on the keys without making a sound, and then gently press with finger 3 alone. She starts with finger 3, the middle finger, then goes through 2, 4, 5 and 1, one at a time. Finger 3 is the easiest to control, and once its base joint is firm, the others collapse less easily. Finger numbers are explained in Piano Finger Numbers. For a student who already plays, she corrects one note in a piece at a time, and thinks of progress in units of half a year.

A column in PTNA’s “100 Lesson Points” series, entry 002, titled “Everything natural: natural fingers, natural body” (2009), says that a good finger is the natural shape the hand has when you do nothing. Left alone, the fingers curve slightly inward because of how the joints work, and anyone resting a hand naturally on a table puts it down in a good shape.

The same entry says that small children with weak fingertips sometimes play with flat, stretched fingers so that their nails show. Putting weight into the fingertip needs a fingertip joint that does not cave in, and the “good hand shape” is one where you cannot see your own nails. The column suggests asking “Is that a good hand?” when the shape slips, or simply saying “nails” when the nails start to show.

Teachers do not all agree on finger shape. The 2013 report sets out the view that the fingers should stand upright on the keys next to views that prefer a flatter finger, and notes that opinions on finger shape are divided among teachers.

Shoulders, elbows and wrists

In number 19 of the same Q&A series (2018), a teacher asked about an elementary school student whose wrists drop. The answer, from Hitomi Itokazu, notes that many elementary school students, especially in the lower grades, are not yet physically developed enough, which makes good posture hard. Her exercises begin with letting the student feel what relaxed shoulders and elbows are like. When the student plays, she writes, always check that there is no extra tension in the shoulders and elbows, and that the wrists have not dropped.

Sources

  • Yamaha Corporation, Musical Instrument Guide, “Correct Posture When Playing the Piano”.
  • PTNA, teachers’ Q&A no. 25, “Teaching students with weak fingertips”, Yukiko Watanabe (8 May 2019, in Japanese).
  • PTNA, teachers’ Q&A no. 19, “Training to improve hand form”, Hitomi Itokazu (16 October 2018, in Japanese).
  • PTNA, “100 Lesson Points”, entry 002, “Everything natural” (4 December 2009, in Japanese).
  • PTNA research reports, “A comparison of teaching methods for basic piano technique” (19 July 2013, in Japanese).

About Kinder Piano

Kinder Piano is a piano app for iPhone and iPad for children from about age 3 to the early years of elementary school. I made it for my four-year-old daughter.

It shows a score in treble and bass clef, highlights the next note, puts the finger number above it and lights up the key to press. In Slow mode the app waits for each key, so a child can check the notes one at a time. Besides the on-screen keyboard, it connects to Bluetooth and USB MIDI keyboards. All 21 nursery songs are free, as are the first classical piece and the first ear training level, free play and MIDI connection. A single one-time purchase opens the rest of the classical pieces and every ear training level. There are no ads and no subscription.

The path to the first song is in Getting Started with Kinder Piano.

Download on the App Store

Kinder PianoA first piano for little hands