Where Silent Night Comes From: First Sung in an Oberndorf Church in 1818

On the night of 24 December 1818, at St. Nicholas church in Oberndorf near Salzburg, a new song was sung during Christmas mass. Its German title was âStille Nacht! Heilige Nacht!â. In English we know it as âSilent Nightâ.
The Silent Night Association (Stille Nacht Gesellschaft), based in Oberndorf, keeps a detailed history of the song on its website, with pages on each author, the surviving manuscripts and the songâs spread. This post follows those pages, and the entry for the song in Austriaâs national inventory of intangible cultural heritage, in order.
The poem: Mariapfarr, 1816
The words are by Joseph Mohr. The Associationâs page on Mohr says he was born in the city of Salzburg on 11 December 1792 and was ordained a priest in 1815. His first post was as assistant priest in Mariapfarr, in the Lungau region of Salzburg, from 1815 to 1817.
According to the Associationâs history of the song, Mohr wrote the text of âSilent Night!â as a poem in Mariapfarr in 1816.
We know this because a score in Mohrâs own hand was found in 1995. It is the only one by Mohr that survives. In the lower left it says âText von Joseph Mohr mpia Coadjutor 1816â, which the Association translates as âText by Joseph Mohr, confirmed by my own signature, assistant priest 1816â. The score itself is thought to date from between 1820 and 1825, and the â1816â is taken to be the year he wrote the words. In the upper right is the line âMelodie von Fr. Xav. Gruberâ (âMelody by Fr. Xav. Gruberâ), which settled the old question of who wrote the tune.
Mohr moved to Oberndorf in 1817 and left again for his next post in 1819. He served in a long line of villages around Salzburg after that, and died in Wagrain on 4 December 1848.
The melody: Arnsdorf, 1818
The melody is by Franz Xaver Gruber. The Associationâs page on Gruber says he was born on 25 November 1787 in Hochburg, in Upper Austria, and worked as a weaver until he was 18. From 1807 he was schoolteacher, church caretaker and organist in Arnsdorf, and from 1816 he also played the organ for the new parish of Oberndorf.
He wrote the melody in the schoolhouse in Arnsdorf. The same page says Gruber himself called it merely âa simple compositionâ.
Christmas Eve, 1818
Gruber described that day in a document dated 30 December 1854, his âAuthentic Account of the Origin of the Christmas Carolâ. The Association quotes its opening in English:
âIt was the 24th of December of the year 1818, when the then assistant priest Joseph Mohr at the newly established parish of St. Nicholas in Oberndorf handed over to the organist represented by Franz Gruber (who at the time was also school teacher in Arnsdorf) a poem, with the request to write a fitting melody for 2 solo voices together with choir and for accompaniment by guitar.â
Later that same day, Gruber brought Mohr the finished music. Mohr liked it, so the song went into the Christmas mass that evening. Mohr sang the tenor part and played the guitar, and Gruber sang bass. The congregation was mostly boatmen, boat builders and their families, and according to Gruber the song met with âgeneral approval by allâ.
Gruberâs first score for that night was in D major, in 6/8 time, for two solo voices and choir with guitar. It is now lost. The church is gone too. A Silent Night memorial chapel stands on the site of St. Nicholas church.
Six verses
The Associationâs Text and Music page prints all six verses, following a score Gruber wrote around 1860. The first verse opens:
Stille Nacht! Heilige Nacht!
Alles schläft; einsam wacht
All six verses begin with the same line, âStille Nacht! Heilige Nacht!â. Mohrâs own score also has six verses. Its title is âWeynachts Liedâ (Christmas song), and it is in D major, in 6/8 time, for two voices with guitar.
The Association knows of eight scores in the hands of the two authors, counting Gruberâs lost first one. There are versions for voices and choir alone, with organ, and with orchestra, and the number of verses differs from one to another.
The history page also points to the fourth verse. Mariapfarr, where Mohr wrote the poem, had suffered greatly during the withdrawal of the Bavarian occupation troops in 1816 and 1817, and Mohr saw it happen. With this in mind, the Association writes, the fourth verse âtakes on special meaningâ. Its text âexpresses a great longing for peace and comfortâ.
When the authors were forgotten
The Associationâs page on the spreading of the song says the first written copies come from around the places where Mohr and Gruber worked. A singer of Salzburg Cathedral wrote it down in 1822. The names of the authors, though, were soon forgotten.
Beyond Salzburg, the song travelled through the Zillertal valley in Tyrol. In his account, Gruber wrote that a âwell-known Zillertalerâ took it to Tyrol, and the Association identifies him as the organ builder Carl Mauracher. Mauracher repaired the organ in Arnsdorf in 1821, and rebuilt the organ of the Oberndorf church in 1825.
From the Zillertal, two singing families carried it further: the Rainers of FĂźgen and the Strassers of Laimach. The first recorded performance is a concert by the Strasser siblings in Leipzig on 15 December 1832. The Leipziger Tagblatt newspaper wrote that the singers had fulfilled the wish, expressed in its pages, that they sing âthe beautiful Christmas carol âSilent Night! Holy Night!ââ.
After the Leipzig concerts, around 1833, the publisher A. R. Friese of Dresden and Leipzig printed the song for the first time, in a booklet called âVier echte Tyroler Liederâ (âFour genuine Tyrolean songsâ). The authorsâ names were missing, and the song had been changed a great deal.
1854: a question from Berlin
In 1854 the Royal Prussian Court Chapel in Berlin wrote to the Benedictine monastery of St. Peter in Salzburg to ask who had written the song. By then it took some searching even in Salzburg to find out. Gruberâs reply was the account of 30 December 1854 quoted above.
In its home province of Salzburg, the song had its breakthrough only in 1866, when it was included in the âofficialâ church songbook. By then neither author was alive. Gruber had been choir director and organist at the parish church of Hallein from 1835, and died on 7 June 1863.
By the turn of the twentieth century, the Association writes, Catholic and Protestant missionaries had brought âSilent Night!â to every continent.
2011: Austriaâs intangible cultural heritage
In 2011 the Austrian Commission for UNESCO added âSilent Nightâ, the Christmas carol, to Austriaâs national inventory of intangible cultural heritage, under social practices, for the whole of Austria.
The inventory entry says the song is well known in every Austrian province and is passed down from generation to generation within communities, associations and families. Church communities of various faiths, choirs, singing societies, kindergartens and schools all sing it. It has been translated into some 300 languages.
The stories behind other songs in Kinder Piano are in Where Twinkle, Twinkle Comes From and Ode to Joy and Japanâs Year-End Ninth. How to plan practice for a Christmas song is in When Should Kids Start Practicing Christmas Songs on Piano?.
Sources
- Silent Night Association, âHistory of the Songâ.
- Silent Night Association, âJoseph Mohrâ and âFranz Xaver Gruberâ.
- Silent Night Association, âSpreading of the Songâ.
- Silent Night Association, âText and Musicâ.
- Austrian Commission for UNESCO, entry for âSilent Nightâ, the Christmas carol, in the national inventory of intangible cultural heritage.
About Kinder Piano
Kinder Piano is a piano app for iPhone and iPad for children from about age 3 to the early years of elementary school. I made it for my four-year-old daughter. âSilent Nightâ is in the Songs tab, marked Normal.
It shows a score in treble and bass clef, highlights the next note and lights up the key to press. In Slow mode the app waits for each key, so a child can check the notes one at a time. Besides the on-screen keyboard, it connects to Bluetooth and USB MIDI keyboards. All 21 nursery songs are free, as are the first classical piece and the first ear training level, free play and MIDI connection. A single one-time purchase opens the rest of the classical pieces and every ear training level. There are no ads and no subscription.
The path to the first song is in Getting Started with Kinder Piano.
Kinder PianoA first piano for little handsSee the app â